Roy Keane makes brutal Man Utd Premier League prediction and disagrees with Gary Neville

Roy Keane has punctured the feeling of optimism around Manchester United after their opening match of the Premier League season ended in defeat. United were beaten 1-0 by Arsenal at Old Trafford on Sunday as two familiar problems continued for Ruben Amorim’s side.

Riccardo Calafiori scored the only goal of the game with a close-range header early on after Altay Bayindir flapped at Declan Rice’s corner. There were United Premier League debuts for £200million new signings Matheus Cunha, Bryan Mbeumo and Benjamin Sesko, but David Raya left with a clean sheet.

United struggled in the goalkeeping department last season, where Andre Onana was inconsistent, while they managed just 44 goals in 38 matches in 2024/25. Nevertheless, Amorim sounded a note of optimism post-match, claiming “we were not boring” – an analysis which was quickly dismissed by Keane.

Asked on Sky Sports if there was grounds for optimism, Keane replied: “Yeah, I think with the couple of signings that have come in and we saw today, I was encouraged by that. They looked like Man United players, they were happy to deal with the pressure, they’re good characters.

READ MORE: Ruben Amorim tells Mikel Arteta 'we were the better team' as Man Utd halted by Arsenal

READ MORE: Ruben Amorim and Bruno Fernandes in agreement on controversial Man Utd vs Arsenal moment

“But we’ve mentioned it many times before, there are problems at the back. We’ve heard noises about them not being boring, but ultimately you’ve got to score goals to win football matches or you’re constantly under pressure.

“The expectations around the club are so low now that everyone is almost happy.” Later he was asked to predict where his old club would finish. “Mid-table – 10th, maybe ninth,” he said.

Summing up his feelings, he added: “The expectations at United now are so low, that even Gary [Neville] said on commentary, everyone is OK with a 1-0 defeat. They’ve got to do better. It does worry me.

“Some of the new signings, there was encouragement with that. They were getting you up the pitch with a bit of power. Things will improve, it’s tough against Arsenal, but no goals and another defeat. There’s still problems there with Man United.”

Mbeumo and Cunha troubled Arsenal’s defence and showed signs of a good understanding before Sesko came off the bench in the second half. Amorim has now won just seven of his 28 league games and after finishing 15th last season, Keane explained what should come next.

"I think it's about trying to rebuild the team, get some confidence, get some momentum early in the season. Last year, obviously nowhere near good enough, we know that,” he said before kick-off.

HAVE YOUR SAY! Where will Manchester United finish this season? Comment below.

"The biggest issue they had all season despite chatting about the goalkeeper and the defence, they didn't score enough goals. When you're not scoring enough goals, particularly if you're Manchester United when they've invested so much money, you're constantly under pressure.

"They've obviously tried to fix that this summer. The signings, looking at them in pre-season, I know it's still early but yeah, the signs are good.

"They've obviously brought two players in who know the Premiership, they're robust enough to deal with the challenge of that and obviously they needed a goalscorer, so they were constantly under pressure. Looking at it, I like the look of it."

Join our new MAN UTD WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Manchester United content from Mirror Football. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.